How to Break the Cycle of the Four Horsemen in Relationships
In any relationship, conflict is inevitable, but how couples handle that conflict determines whether their bond will grow stronger or weaken over time. Dr. John Gottman, a leading relationship researcher, identified four negative communication patterns that can significantly harm relationships if left unchecked. These patterns are known as the Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse: Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness, and Stonewalling. When these behaviors dominate communication, they can lead to emotional disconnection, resentment, and eventually, the breakdown of the relationship.
The good news is that each of the Four Horsemen has an antidote—an alternative behavior that can help reverse these damaging patterns. In this post, we’ll dive into what the Four Horsemen are, how to recognize them in your relationship, and most importantly, how to break the cycle to create a healthier, more loving dynamic.
The Four Horsemen: What They Are and Why They’re Harmful
1. Criticism
What it looks like: Criticism involves attacking your partner’s character or personality, rather than focusing on specific behaviors or actions. It often sounds like, “You never help around the house,” or, “You’re so selfish.”
Why it’s harmful: Criticism makes your partner feel attacked and inadequate, leading to defensiveness or emotional withdrawal. Over time, it erodes trust and creates a toxic atmosphere.
2. Contempt
What it looks like: Contempt is the most destructive of the Four Horsemen and involves treating your partner with disrespect, sarcasm, mockery, or eye-rolling. It may sound like, “Oh, you’re so pathetic,” or, “I can’t believe you’re that dumb.”
Why it’s harmful: Contempt conveys a sense of superiority and disgust toward your partner, which is incredibly damaging to their self-esteem. It often leads to feelings of shame and rejection, fueling resentment and deepening emotional distance.
3. Defensiveness
What it looks like: Defensiveness occurs when you make excuses, deny responsibility, or shift the blame to your partner during a conflict. For example, if your partner says, “You didn’t tell me we had plans tonight,” a defensive response might be, “Well, you never listen when I talk, so that’s your fault.”
Why it’s harmful: Defensiveness escalates the conflict by deflecting responsibility and prevents productive communication. It makes your partner feel unheard and invalidated, which keeps the issue unresolved.
4. Stonewalling
What it looks like: Stonewalling happens when one partner emotionally shuts down and withdraws from the conversation. This might involve refusing to engage, walking away, or simply giving the silent treatment during arguments.
Why it’s harmful: Stonewalling leaves your partner feeling abandoned and isolated, making it impossible to resolve conflicts. Over time, it can create an emotional divide that’s difficult to bridge.
The Antidotes: How to Break the Cycle
While the Four Horsemen can severely damage a relationship, they’re not inevitable. By practicing the antidotes to these toxic behaviors, you can transform the way you communicate and create a healthier, more respectful dynamic.
1. Criticism Antidote: Use Gentle Startups
What to do instead: Replace criticism with a gentle startup. Instead of attacking your partner’s character, focus on specific behaviors and use “I” statements to express how you feel without placing blame.
Example: Instead of saying, “You never help with the dishes,” try, “I feel overwhelmed when the dishes pile up. Could we work together to keep the kitchen tidy?”
Why it works: A gentle startup focuses on the issue at hand and invites collaboration, making your partner more receptive to addressing the problem without feeling attacked.
2. Contempt Antidote: Build a Culture of Appreciation
What to do instead: The antidote to contempt is cultivating appreciation and respect for your partner. Make an effort to notice and express gratitude for the things your partner does well, rather than focusing on their flaws.
Example: If you feel frustrated by something your partner did, pause and reflect on something positive they’ve done recently. Instead of sarcastically saying, “You never do anything right,” try saying, “I really appreciated it when you helped with the groceries earlier. It made my day easier.”
Why it works: Contempt destroys emotional safety, but appreciation and admiration rebuild it. Expressing gratitude helps counter negative feelings and strengthens the emotional connection between you and your partner.
3. Defensiveness Antidote: Take Responsibility
What to do instead: Instead of becoming defensive, practice taking responsibility for your part in the conflict. Acknowledge your partner’s feelings and accept that you might have contributed to the problem, even if unintentionally.
Example: If your partner says, “You forgot to pick up the dry cleaning,” avoid responding with excuses like, “You didn’t remind me.” Instead, say, “You’re right. I forgot. I’ll pick it up tomorrow.”
Why it works: Taking responsibility shows that you’re willing to work together to solve the problem, rather than deflecting blame. It also validates your partner’s perspective and helps de-escalate the situation.
4. Stonewalling Antidote: Practice Physiological Self-Soothing
What to do instead: When you feel emotionally overwhelmed and tempted to stonewall, practice self-soothing techniques to calm yourself down. This might involve taking deep breaths, stepping away from the conversation for a short break, or finding a quiet space to collect your thoughts.
Example: If you notice yourself shutting down during an argument, say something like, “I’m feeling overwhelmed right now. Can we take a 10-minute break and come back to this?” During the break, focus on calming your body and mind.
Why it works: Stonewalling often happens because of emotional flooding—when you’re so overwhelmed that you can’t think clearly. Self-soothing helps regulate your emotions, allowing you to re-enter the conversation with a clearer mind and more patience.
Breaking the Cycle: Additional Tips
Practice Regular Check-ins: Set aside time for open, honest conversations about your relationship outside of moments of conflict. This helps prevent the buildup of resentment and keeps both partners feeling connected.
Use Positive Reinforcement: When your partner uses the antidotes to the Four Horsemen, acknowledge it. Positive reinforcement encourages healthier communication patterns.
Seek Professional Help: If the Four Horsemen have become deeply entrenched in your relationship, consider working with a couples therapist who can provide tools and strategies to break the cycle.
Focus on Repair Attempts: During or after conflict, small gestures of kindness, humor, or affection can help repair emotional damage and bring you back into connection with one another. These repair attempts are key to maintaining a healthy relationship.
Transforming Your Relationship Through Better Communication
The Four Horsemen—Criticism, Contempt, Defensiveness, and Stonewalling—are harmful communication patterns that can erode trust, intimacy, and emotional connection in a relationship. But they don’t have to be permanent. By recognizing these behaviors and implementing the antidotes—gentle startups, appreciation, taking responsibility, and self-soothing—you can break the cycle and create a healthier, more resilient relationship.
Change won’t happen overnight, but with practice and commitment, you and your partner can build a stronger, more supportive foundation that helps you navigate conflict with respect, empathy, and love.
By addressing these negative patterns early and consistently practicing their antidotes, you can significantly improve your relationship's communication and long-term health.
Reflection Questions
Do you notice criticism creeping into your conversations with your partner?
Reflect on how you express frustrations. Are your complaints focused on specific behaviors, or do they attack your partner’s character?How often do you or your partner show signs of contempt, such as sarcasm, eye-rolling, or mockery?
Consider whether contempt has entered your relationship. How does it impact the way you feel about each other during disagreements?Do you find yourself becoming defensive when your partner brings up issues?
Think about how you typically respond to feedback. Do you take responsibility for your part in the problem, or do you deflect blame and make excuses?Do you or your partner tend to shut down or withdraw during conflicts?
Reflect on whether stonewalling is present in your relationship. How does emotional withdrawal affect your ability to resolve conflicts and stay connected?How willing are you to practice the antidotes to these negative patterns?
Are you open to using techniques like gentle startups, practicing appreciation, and taking responsibility? How can you and your partner support each other in breaking the cycle of the Four Horsemen?
Related Posts You Might Enjoy: